Court’s Erroneous Admission of Gang Evidence Resulted in Reversal of Murder Convictions

By: Wallin & Klarich

In a recent decision by the California Court of Appeals, it was held that the trial court erred in admitting irrelevant and highly prejudicial gang evidence of the defendants’ membership in a motorcycle club, where there was no evidence that the club was a street gang or a criminal enterprise, and where the prosecution offered this evidence in its case-in-chief primarily to show defendants’ criminal disposition to commit murder. (People v. Memory (March 5, 2010) Case No. Co54422.)

In California, evidence that defendants are members of a certain street gang is relevant to prove identity of those individuals suspected of violating the law. Moreover, gang evidence is relevant and admissible when the very reason for the underlying crime is related to gang activities. In Memory, however, the prosecution offered gang related evidence that the defendants were members of the Jus Brothers motorcycle gang. The prosecution wanted to show that membership in this gang required the members to carry knives and to fight when challenged by other people.

The court held that evidence of gang membership could not be introduced to prove intent or culpability of the defendants. The court found the evidence to be irrelevant. The evidence could not be admitted at trial where its sole relevance was to show defendants’ criminal disposition or bad character as a means of creating an inference that the defendant committed the homicide. By admitting this highly inflammatory and irrelevant evidence, the trial court committed reversible error resulted in a miscarriage of justice requiring reversal of defendants’ convictions.

Our firm has over 30 years of experience in representing clients in criminal matters and has been recognized as an AV rated law firm. Wallin and Klarich offers outstanding representation to clients charged with gang related crimes.
buy augmentin online no prescription

We have the legal knowledge and the resources to ensure that your rights are protected. Please call our Southern California criminal appeals lawyers at (888) 280-6839 or visit our website at We will be there when you call.
buy bactroban online no prescription

Posted In: Criminal Appeals